hmmm, not too sure about this one Tyler…
As a lover of fine hotels, I disagree that the club sandwich is a good way to rank hotels, for a number of reasons.
1) A club sandwich is not a simple affair. It’s the mother of all sandwiches, requiring much skill to master an assemblage of 10 simple, yet very different ingredients.
2) With hotels across the world I think a Club sandwich is an unfair expectation, as the fundamental concept and many ingredients would be foreign imports. This is not only makes it ridiculously expensive and unsustainable – but sets up for immediate failure. A perfectly executed local dish would be much better suited – say a curry in Sri Lanka, sushi or soba in Japan, steak frites in Paris or a club sandwich in New York.
3) Room Service is never going to be the optimum environment for the consumption of such a sandwich – or most food for that matter. The kitchens are just not close enough to ensure everything arrives is perfect condition, especially if you are in a large hotel. The chips, crisped bread and lettuce are more than likely going arrive luke warm and sweaty. If it must evaluate the club sandwich, it would be best served in the restaurant or bar where it comes promptly sans silver dome.